menu
menu
Sports

Cummins’ Sandpapergate defence contradicted by new evidence

Will Macpherson
15/11/2026 10:55:00
Pat Cummins rebutted claims over his knowledge of the plot in a 70-minute press conference on Friday - Reuters/Jeremy Piper
Pat Cummins rebutted claims over his knowledge of the plot in a 70-minute press conference on Friday - Reuters/Jeremy Piper
Pat Cummins rebutted claims over his knowledge of the plot in a 70-minute press conference on Friday - Reuters/Jeremy Piper

Pat Cummins’ account of the sandpaper scandal has been called into question by a member of Australia’s touring party to South Africa in 2018.

Australian cricket has been at war this week following the release of Usman Khawaja’s autobiography Sabr, in which he blew open the sandpaper saga eight years on by claiming that all players knew about a plot to tamper with the ball.

Cummins, Australia’s Test captain, responded with a 68-minute press conference on Friday, dismissing Khawaja’s claims as “complete and utter nonsense”.

Chadd Sayers, a South Australian fast bowler who played his only Test the week after Australian cricket was rocked by sandpapergate, supported Khawaja’s testimony in an interview with SEN radio before the second ODI against England in Adelaide.

Sayers made a series of as-yet unverified claims, including:

“I’m pretty confident to say that everyone knew,” Sayers said. “I just knew that it was going to be used as I believe everyone else did. The plan was that Cameron Bancroft was going to take that out, the ball was going to be dropped on the on the ground by the umpires and he was going to go about business.”

He added that he became aware of its use a Test earlier than Australia were rumbled: “In Port Elizabeth, so as it’s known now, it was used in two test matches and there was discussions in change rooms of how we were going to get the ball to reverse and what was going to be used.

“It is eight years ago, so my recollection isn’t as clear as it was obviously eight years ago. I just know that there was numerous conversations of it around in the change rooms.”

Chadd Sayers during his only Test match appearance for Australia in Johannesburg in 2018 - Getty Images/Lee Warren
Chadd Sayers during his only Test match appearance for Australia in Johannesburg in 2018 - Getty Images/Lee Warren

Sayers revealed an occasion where he took the sandpaper from the field after it had been used on the ball.

“[The sandpaper] was given to me to take off. That wasn’t planned or anything. I was just the player who took the drinks out at the time. I recall it was a wicket or a drinks break after tea,” Sayers said.

He also spoke about the notion of taking collective responsibility. Khawaja said he had pushed for this, but claimed two players in the team did not want to take responsibility. Cummins denied any knowledge of such conversations.

“Yes, after the occurrence in Cape Town, we all sat in the change rooms after that day’s play and probably for 60 to 90 minutes,” he alleged.

“We talked about what had happened and I guess where to next.

“I guess it was always going to happen with this seriousness of what the allegations were. So, it was just as I said, it was about what had happened, where we stood with that and how we were going to move forward.

“I guess at that stage we probably didn’t know the severity back in Australia as well.”

Asked about what he made of Cummins’ press conference, Sayers said “it felt a bit awkward”.

“I didn’t like how he [Cummins] did go at Usman and got personal,” he said. “I probably get why but I don’t think it needed to happen.”

Bancroft received a nine-month ban by CA for his role in the scandal, with Smith and Warner both handed one-year suspensions.

David Warner (left to right), Cameron Bancroft and Steve Smith were the only players punished for the plot - Reuters/Andrew Boyers
David Warner (left to right), Cameron Bancroft and Steve Smith were the only players punished for the plot - Reuters/Andrew Boyers

In a statement, CA accepted that a consensus among players was “unlikely” to be found “without relevant material evidence”, but there is no suggestion a new investigation is about to be opened.

“We respect the right of those in South Africa in 2018 to share their version of what they believe happened on that tour,” a CA spokesperson said.

“The significant differences in the views expressed continues to demonstrate that it is very unlikely an agreed version of events will be reached without relevant material evidence.”

Where this all leaves Cummins is unclear. He spoke about not addressing the issue again at his press conference, but the two sides still have significant differences in their versions.

Warner was due to commentate for Fox on the second ODI, but was a late withdrawal because he returned to Sydney for a “family commitment”, according to the station. He is due to return for Wednesday’s third ODI in Hobart, and has made clear he has plenty more to say on the matter. On Sunday he put out another Instagram post, clarifying another from a day earlier where he questioned whether the CA investigation interviewed Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc and Nathan Lyon.

“Just to clarify ‘As far as I am aware’ was the POINT,” he wrote. “I was never told the bowlers had been interviewed or provided statements.

“That information would’ve been pretty useful when I was forced to make decisions back in 2018. Why weren’t we given all the evidence by CA?”

by The Telegraph