Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s Ineos and Sir Ben Ainslie’s Athena Racing have reached an out-of-court settlement over the £180m America’s Cup boat and other assets they were embroiled in a bitter dispute over.
The settlement, details of which have not been disclosed, means the dispute will not now go to the High Court and Ainslie’s team can compete in next year’s America’s Cup in Naples without the shadow of a costly legal battle hanging over their heads.
The AC75 boat is already in Naples, having undergone a major refit at Persico in northern Italy, and is expected to take to the water some time around the start of December.
Telegraph Sport exclusively reported at last month’s AC38 preliminary regatta in Naples that the two parties were in talks to settle, with the first available trial date at the High Court not until after next summer’s Cup had already taken place.
HM Courts subsequently confirmed that the case was scheduled to be heard in the Admiralty Court in January 2028, six months after next summer’s Cup ends in July.
Ineos’s last throw of the dice had been an application in September for a trial of “certain preliminary issues”, an attempt to have some questions settled early and separately, including ownership of the boat.
The judge dismissed it, ordering instead “a single trial of all issues in these proceedings”. It made sense for all parties to avoid dragging out a costly legal battle and comes at a time where Ratcliffe’s Ineos is also managing the latest managerial crisis at Manchester United, the football club it co-owns with the Glazer family, following the sacking of Michael Carrick.
The settlement ends one of the most acrimonious sporting disputes of recent times.
Despite their historic success in the second of their two campaigns together – Ineos Britannia became the first British team to win the America’s Cup challenger series in Barcelona in 2024, before going down 7-2 to defenders New Zealand in the final – Ainslie and Ratcliffe fell out spectacularly at the conclusion of that Cup about the running of the team and who owned the intellectual property (IP) and assets.
Ratcliffe argued that having ploughed in as much as $350m (£265m) over the course of the two campaigns, as well as bringing partners Mercedes F1 to the table, he owned the assets. Ainslie’s contention was that Ineos was always a sponsor rather than the owner of the team and that the assets belonged to Athena Racing.
These included “certain other vessels”. There was also a simulator and associated tools housed at Mercedes F1’s headquarters at Brackley, to which GB1, Ainslie’s team, had been denied access since the last Cup. Presumably, that is now winging its way out to Naples.
Earlier this year, The Telegraph exclusively revealed that Ratcliffe was suing Ainslie in an attempt to get him to hand over the “£180m boat” they built together. This posed an existential threat to the team, who are now backed by Peter Dubens’ Oakley Capital.
Athena hit back, with High Court documents in late May alleging that Ainslie was warned by representatives of Ratcliffe on the eve of the last Cup that the British billionaire would “burn his house down” unless he handed over the team’s assets and intellectual property. “We have a phrase at Ineos: ‘scorched earth’,” Ainslie claims he was told.
The filing also included an allegation of “false imprisonment”, in January last year, immediately after their split, when Ainslie and his Athena colleagues allegedly found themselves locked inside their own Northamptonshire offices by an Ineos employee and two security contractors who turned up at the premises. Lawyers for Ineos claimed the company’s representative did not know anyone was inside the building at the time the doors were locked.
In a terse statement released on Monday morning, an Ineos spokesman said: “Ineos has reached a settlement with Athena Racing and considers the matter now closed.”
GB1 then released a similarly succinct statement saying: “Ineos has reached a settlement with Athena Racing and considers the matter now closed.”
When asked about ownership of assets, a spokesman for the team added: “Athena Racing/GB1 have always been, and remain, the owners of their assets. The terms of the settlement are confidential, and we will not be commenting further on the details.”
It seems likely both parties have paid their own legal fees rather than test the case in court. The costs of the hearing and Ineos’s failed application were “in the case”, so whoever lost at trial was due to pick up the bill.
The Royal Yacht Squadron, under whose flag GB1 competes, released a statement to its members on Monday saying: “Members will no doubt be aware of the ongoing commercial dispute between Ineos and Athena Racing/GB1.
“I am delighted to announce that this dispute has now been settled, with any and all claims between the parties now withdrawn.”