Another World Cup, another moment of unwanted history for Germany. Even though this Germany team got out of the group, unlike in Qatar and Russia, the disappointment of this exit in the USA, Canada and Mexico sits just as deep. For the first time in their history, Germany lost a World Cup game on penalties. For the second time in a week, Germany played the game their opponents wanted rather than taking control themselves. And, for the third straight World Cup, Germany failed to meet expectations.
"Only thing I can say is I'm sorry. To disappoint again is not a nice feeling," Kai Havertz, who missed one of Germany's penalties, told public broadcaster ZDF afterwards. "We tried to [attack via] the flanks, but unfortunately it didn't really work out. And I don't think we deserved to win this time."
"Even though the elimination hurts: What a game," German Chancellor Friedrich Merz wrote on social media. "With your dedication and team spirit at this World Cup, you've inspired our country. We're proud of you."
From its diversity to its team spirit, there are indeed many inspirational sources in this current Germany team. Sadly, when they needed an inspirational performance, they couldn't find one.
Ecuador loss a factor
Beforehand, Germany head coach Julian Nagelsmann said his team needed to adapt a "scumbag mentality" in order to progress. There was little of that tenacity on offer from Germany. This was a side that looked tentative for too long and indecisive when it mattered. Despite coming back from a goal down in normal time, and denying Paraguay the winning penalty twice, Germany were unable to win. It turns out a lot more was lost in New York New Jersey Stadium than just the game against Ecuador.
The momentum that Germany lost with that defeat hung over their heads in Boston just four days later. Despite Deniz Undav starting, Julian Nagelsmann's side looked ponderous. Over half an hour in, Germany had completed seven times as many passes as their opponents. Paraguay were asking, perhaps even daring Germany to break them down. Germany couldn't find a way.
Paraguay did, with their first real foray forward. A recycled corner led to an unmarked Julio Enciso, just 168 centimeters (5 feet, 5 inches) tall, heading home from near the penalty spot. It was a poor look for Germany's defense, but also an indictment on the harmlessness of Germany's attack.
Germany were huffing and puffing, again, but not really finding the answers. For the third straight game in this tournament, Germany needed something to spark them into life. This time, it was the tactical change to cross the ball more that brought the equalizer. Kai Havertz's glancing header was enough to claw Germany back. Initially, it felt like the moment the game would change and Germany would earn a gritty, ugly 2-1 win.
However, like Germany at World Cups of late, the equalizer proved to be a false dawn. So too was Jonathan Tah's disallowed goal in extra time. The defender's header was ruled out for a foul in the build-up in a decision Nagelsmann called "scandalous." He also admitted though, that Germany should have decided the game beforehand.
They didn't. And so, when Kai Havertz and Nick Woltemade missed in the shootout, Germany's tournament looked like it was done. The door opened for one final twist though, when Antonio Sanabria fired wide, Paraguay's victory in his hands. When Neuer denied Fabian Balbuena with a strong save, Germany looked like they really might have leapt from the jaws of defeat. But Tah, playing in his first World Cup, blazed the first penalty in sudden death over, and Jose Canale sealed Paraguay's win at the third time of asking. Fittingly for this team of false dawns and slow starts, their defeat came by a thousand cuts rather than one swift blow.
The fallout
Losing 4-3 on penalties after a 1-1 draw at the end of extra-time — how did Germany let it come to this? Much will be asked after an exit like this. For Neuer, his return offered little more than a few records. Germany captain Joshua Kimmich's international career is now littered with disappointments. At 31 years old, it is fair to wonder whether he will even be at Euro 2028. Antonio Rüdiger (33), Leon Goretzka (31) and Leroy Sane (30) are likely not coming back. Significant change lies ahead.
More importantly, what of Julian Nagelsmann? His contract, after a surprising extension in early 2025, runs until 2028.
"I'm here to work and if the DFB decides otherwise then they should tell me," Nagelsmann said afterwards. "I'm not the type of person who runs away."
This Germany team though, are running right out of this World Cup as the country confirms its place outside of football's elite. Another introspective analysis of the health of the beautiful game in Germany will follow. Fingers will be pointed. Questions will be asked. And so begins another long road to trying to restore this football nation to the top table.
Edited by: Wesley Dockery